"Men’s choirs are a safe space for men"

A conversation with Luis Mosebach (28), 2nd Chair and 2nd bass in the Edelweiss Buchenbach Men’s Choir e. V.

Many male choirs today are struggling with a lack of new recruits and a rather outdated image. Luis Mosebach sees things differently – and explains why the male choir has become one of the most important parts of his life.

Luis, how did you end up joining the men’s choir in the first place?
I used to sing in the school choir, and my mum was in the church choir, so it wasn’t entirely unfamiliar to me. Then there was a long break. A friend’s father persuaded me to join the men’s choir in Buchenbach. At first, I tended to joke about it and thought: ‘What am I going to do there? It’s just a bunch of older people.’ Then I just went along – and was completely proven wrong.

In what way?
I was welcomed like I’ve rarely been anywhere else: warmly and without any reservations about me being a young bloke. I’d never experienced that sort of openness in a group before. Today I’d say: that’s one of the best things that’s ever happened to me.

And what do you think makes a men’s choir so special?
The sense of community. They’re comrades – an old-fashioned word, but it fits: friends with whom you’re on a journey. And: this group is extremely free of prejudice. You might not expect that in a village – but I’ve rarely experienced such open conversations. And musically: the sound of male voices is something in a class of its own. The range is vast – from Gregorian chant and folk songs to gospel, jazz or pop. We sing all of that in Buchenbach – that cliché about a folk music choir simply isn’t true. What’s more: it helps you slow down. When you’re singing, you’re at one with yourself – your breathing, your voice and your concentration take on an almost meditative quality. Others go to yoga; I say: go to choir practice!

You once said: ‘Men’s choirs are a safe space for men.’ What do you mean by that?
In a fast-paced, often turbulent world, it’s a space where you feel understood. It’s not about setting yourself apart at all, but about what you have in common: people who share similar experiences and life journeys come together. That builds trust, and some things are easier to talk about without having to explain too much. Essentially, it’s comparable to other close-knit groups – whether it’s a rural women’s group, a circle of friends or a ‘girls’ night out’: it’s about reliability and shared experiences.

And how important is that sense of community for your choir?
It’s the foundation. Without it, the whole thing would have no soul. The audience senses this connection too – and it leads to better musical results. I believe that’s exactly what makes our concerts special.

Why do male choirs have such big problems recruiting new members these days?
The range of leisure activities on offer is huge – especially online. But that affects many clubs. And for a long time, we failed to make ourselves visible. Jazz and pop choirs have a greater media presence, whereas many traditional choirs are still in a sort of ‘generational slumber’.

So it’s also an image problem?
Yes, indeed. And a transition problem: there are brilliant and large school choirs – especially here in the Dreisamtal – but afterwards there’s a lack of connection to the established choirs, partly because we aren’t visible enough.

You’re a group of 25 active singers – are any new ones joining?
We try to do that by approaching people in person – and often more than once. That’s actually our most important strategy. Nevertheless, we have major problems recruiting new members. Many people are put off and immediately say: ‘I can’t sing.’ We hear this standard excuse very often. Project-based initiatives can help lower this barrier somewhat, but overall it remains difficult. Incidentally, we don’t just approach younger people, but older ones too – for example, those who have recently retired – but even there, it takes patience and persistence.

And how do you see the future of men’s choirs?
I believe they have a future – but not the same as it was 100 years ago. It will require more collaboration: mergers, new projects, shared resources, a more modern presence. But the idea remains. And I definitely want to stick with it for the next 20 or 30 years – including my work with the choir.

Thank you very much!